A black outlined shield icon featuring a simple checkmark in the center, representing security or approval.

Trusted Insurance Carriers-More Choices for Crestview and the Panhandle

As an independent agency, The Holloway Agency partners with a broad network of top-rated insurers-giving you more options and greater peace of mind with every policy.

Companies We Represent

The dark blue Auto-Owners Insurance logo with the tagline
Auto-Owners Insurance

Phone

517.323.1200

Claims:

1.888.252.4626

The logo for American Integrity Insurance Group features a gold
American Integrity

Phone:

866.968.8390

A dark blue logo featuring the letters
American Strategic Insurance (ASI)

Phone:

866.274.8765

Capitol Preferrred Logo
Capitol Preferred Insurance Company

Phone

800.388.2742

Dairyland Insurance Logo
Dairyland

Phone:

800.334.0090

Federated National Logo
Federated National

Phone:

800.293.2532

Foremost Insurance Logo
Foremost Insurance Group

Phone

888.888.0080

Gainsco Auto Insurance Logo
Gainsco

Phone:

866.424.6726

GeoVera Insurance Logo
GeoVera

Phone:

800.324.6020

Haregtry Insurance Logo
Hagerty Insurance

Phone

877.922.9701

Mercury Insurance Logo
Mercury Insurance Group

Phone:

800.503.3724

National General Insurance Logo
National General Insurance

Phone:

800.847.2886

Nationwide Insurance Logo
Nationwide Insurance

Phone

1.877.669.6877

Progressive Insurance Logo
Progressive

Phone:

800.776.4737

The logo for Cabrillo Coastal General Insurance Agency, Inc. featuring a stylized blue wave icon above the company name.
CABRILLO COASTAL

Phone:

866.896.7233

The Safeco Insurance logo, featuring the word
Safeco Insurance

Phone

800.332.3226

The Security First Insurance logo features the text
Security First Insurance

Phone:

877.333.9992

The Southern Fidelity Insurance (SFI) logo features the black lowercase letters
Southern Fidelity

Phone:

866.874.7342

The blue and white St. Johns Insurance Company logo featuring stylized wave graphics.
St. Johns

Phone

800.748.2030

The Titan Insurance logo, featuring the word
Titan Insurance

Phone:

800.848.2687

Logo for Tower Hill Insurance featuring a square icon of a stone tower on a blue background next to the company name.
Tower Hill

Phone:

800.342.3407

The Universal North America logo with the word
Universal of North America

Phone

866.458.4262

Logo for Universal Property and Casualty Insurance Company featuring a red elephant next to a globe in a blue banner.
Universal Property

Phone:

800.425.9113

Logo for Tower Hill Insurance featuring a square icon of a stone tower on a blue background next to the company name.
Tower Hill

Phone:

800.342.3407

Insurance Carriers

Home Insurance


  • American Integrity
  • American Traditions
  • Cabrillo
  • Centauri
  • Citizens
  • Florida Penn/Edison/Ovation
  • Frontline
  • GeoVara
  • Loggerhead
  • Manatee
  • Mangrove
  • Monarch
  • Olympus
  • Patriot Select
  • People’s Trust
  • Progressive
  • SageSure
  • Security First
  • Slide
  • Southern Oak
  • Specialty
  • Tapco
  • Tower Hill
  • Universal
  • Unique

Flood


  • Assurant
  • Neptune

Home and Auto

  • AAA

Auto

  • Auto-Owners
  • Dairyland
  • First Acceptance
  • Foremost/Bristol West
  • Geico
  • Mercury
  • National General
  • Nationwide
  • Progressive

Commercial


  • Auto-Owners
  • Irvin B Green & Associates
  • Nationwide
  • Progressive
  • Tapco
  • US Assure
  • Winston Crum

Take the First Step Today

Need to See Which Carrier Fits You Best?

With so many options, it's our job to help you compare and decide. Contact The Holloway Agency for guidance, quotes, and real answers from a team who knows local insurance inside and out.